UK Babies Aborted for Not Being Perfect

United Kingdom, Daily Mail
28th May 2006 

The ethical storm over abortions has been renewed as it emerged 
that terminations are being carried out for minor, treatable 
birth defects. 

Late terminations have been performed in recent years because 
the babies had club feet, official figures show. 

Babies are being aborted with only minor defects. Other babies 
were destroyed because they had webbed fingers or extra digits. 
Such defects can often be corrected with a simple operation or 
physiotherapy. 

The revelation sparked fears that abortion is increasingly being 
used to satisfy couples' desire for the 'perfect' baby. 

A leading doctor said people were right to be 'totally shocked' 
that abortions were being carried out for such conditions. 

Campaigners warned we are turning into a society that can no 
longer tolerate imperfection. Doctors were recently told they 
can now screen IVF embryos to try to weed out inherited cancers. 

Ethical groups fear parents are opting for abortions because 
they are not told of the support and help available if they 
continued with the pregnancy. 

Details of the terminations emerged as new figures revealed an 
alarming rise in the use of an abortion pill that has been 
linked to 10 deaths. 

Figures from the Office for National Statistics show that 
between 1996 and 2004, 20 babies were aborted after 20 weeks 
because they had a club foot. 

It is one of the most common birth defects in Britain, affecting 
one in 1,000 babies each year. That means around 600 to 700 
babies are born annually in the UK with the problem, which 
causes the feet to point downwards and in severe cases can cause 
a limp. 

However it can be corrected without surgery using splints, 
plaster casts and boots. Naomi Davis, a leading Pediatrician at 
Manchester Children's Hospital who specialists in correcting 
club feet, said: 'I think it is reasonable to be totally shocked 
that abortion is being offered for this. 

'It is entirely treatable. I can only think it is lack of 
information.' 

Figures also show that four babies were aborted since 1996 
because they were found to have webbed fingers or extra digits, 
which can be sorted out with simply surgery. 

Remarkable pictures recently have revealed how at just 23 weeks 
baby in the womb appears to smile, yawn and flinch in pain. 

In 2004 it emerged a baby was aborted at 28 weeks after scans 
showed it had a cleft palate. Curate Joanna Jepson tried to 
ensure criminal charges were brought against the two doctors 
involved but the authorities last year decided against 
prosecution. 

She however vowed to continue in her fight to make terminations 
illegal after 24 weeks and to ensure cleft palates were not 
included within the term 'serious handicap' and used to justify 
late abortions. 

Ms. Jepson reacted angrily to news of the club foot abortions. 

'The law was not designed for this,' she said. 'Actions like 
these are fostering a disposable attitude to human life and I'm 
extremely concerned it is going on. 

'I am appalled that the medical profession is allowing or even 
suggesting abortions for these conditions.' 

Sue Banton, founder of the group Steps for parents of children 
with foot disorders, said last year one couple decided to 
terminate a pregnancy at 25 weeks after discovering their baby 
would have a section of foot missing. 

'We gave them other families to talk to, but they just didn't 
want to know,' she said. 'It is terrible. 

'I know lots of perfectly nice people with this condition and 
you just can't imagine them not being here.' 

Pippa Spriggs from Cambridge, whose son Isaac is celebrating his 
second birthday in July, was dismayed when as scan showed her 
baby had a club foot. 

'Abortion certainly was not openly advised but it was made clear 
to me it was available,' she said. 

'In fact he has been treated and the condition has now slowed 
him down at all.' 

Julia Millington, of the Alive and Kicking Campaign, said: 'It 
is all about our perceptions of perfection. 

'Increasingly things are moving along the lines where nothing is 
good enough. 

'It seems we can no longer tolerate any imperfection. 

'Babies are at the mercy of ultrasound scans and what they may 
disclose.' 

Michaela Aston, from the pro-life group LIFE, said: 'One 
sympathises for many of the parents of these unborn children 
aborted after disability has been detected. 

'What information are they being given by healthcare 
professionals so that they can make a truly informed choice? 

'We suspect that many parents make the decision to opt for 
abortion in complete ignorance of the help and support available 
to children with disabilities and their families. 

'For this, health care professionals must shoulder a large part 
of the blame. 

'If, as a society, we are truly committed to equality for people 
with disabilities then such blatant discrimination against the 
disabled unborn must stop.' 

But Jane Fisher of the Charity Antenatal Results and Choices 
defended the right of parents to terminate pregnancies when 
defects are found. 'This is not part of a move towards designer 
babies,' she said. 

'These are difficult and painful issues.'

______________________________________________________________

For more Disability news issues, see:
www.aapd.com/News/disability/indexdisability.php

# # #

DISCLAIMER: The JFA Listserv is designed to share information
of interest to people with disabilities and promote dialogue
in the disability community. Information circulated does not
necessarily express the views of AAPD. The JFA Listserv is
non-partisan. 

JFA ARCHIVES: All JFA postings from 1995 to present are 
available at: http://www.jfanow.org/jfanow/

MODERATOR, Gwen Gillenwater, JUSTICE FOR ALL -- A Service of
the American Association of People with Disabilities. To 
contact Gwen, please email her at JFAgwen@aol.com.

JOIN AAPD! There's strength in numbers! Be a part of a national
coalition of people with disabilities and join AAPD today at 
http://www.aapd.com.

                  Justice-For-All FREE Subscriptions
                     To subscribe or unsubscribe,
                send an email to majordomo@JFAnow.org
            with subscribe justice OR unsubscribe justice
                 in the body of your email message.